Wed 5 Sep 2007
“Zir head hurts.”
Posted by Sunil under Language/Linguistics
Today I was reading a language/linguistics community online*, and someone, referring to a person of unknown gender referred to “zir abilities” (rather than “his or her abilities”). I thought, “zir???”, and asked a similar question to the poster. Apparently, “zir”, along with “zie”, “zirs” and “zirself”, are one version of gender-neutral pronouns, pronouns invented by… someone… to allow us to not have to say stuff like “His or her head hurts” when the gender of the person is unknown (or unknowable?). As far as language is concerned, I am definitely in the descriptive linguistics camp (those that tend to use linguistics to DESCRIBE language as it changes, in whatever state it evolves to, as opposed to prescriptive linguists, who use linguistics to set rules for language to follow, and the language should not stray too much from these rules… of course, most people are a bit of both and the whole descriptive vs. prescriptive thing is a hot battle in linguistics that this post was not meant to get into…).
Anyway, even with my descriptive leanings, I don’t know if I like “zir”. It’s strange, and probably why nothing like that has caught on, though I guess it does solve a problem. A problem I don’t find myself having very much except when referring to little babies for the first time or with pets whose gender I don’t know yet. What do you think about this type of thing?
* (one of my interests is language/linguistics, although I do not personally speak anything but English fluently, if that. I do, however, enjoy the historical study of the way language, particularly English, has changed over the years, etc.)
September 7th, 2007 at 12:44 am
i’ve always liked “hir” better than “zir”.
September 8th, 2007 at 11:01 pm
hm…i like zir. i think i’m going to start using it.
September 9th, 2007 at 7:20 pm
i’d like to hear you do that!
September 21st, 2007 at 1:02 am
I enjoyed this compact study of language. At times I wonder where the line is between “clever” and “slaughter”. (What? Doesn’t everybody?) We seem to be able to control (many types of) evolution nowadays, so I feel somewhat responsible for whatever I help to perpetuate.